September 20, 2025
What Makes a Book 'Just Right'? Helping Kids Find Their Reading Sweet Spot

Teachers and parents contribute every day to helping children become readers. Reading helps children grow, make sense of the world, and develop their emerging identities. According to Scholastic, over 40% of readers aged six to seventeen say they have a hard time finding books they enjoy reading, and only 28% of caregivers recognize this challenge. The problem is not motivation, but access. Having enough material at their fingertips, and the tools to identify appropriate books, helps young readers find stories that resonate with them. By intentionally encouraging strategies for self-selecting “just-right” books that match their age, reading ability, and interests, we can help children unlock the world of discovery and joy only good books can bring.
Some of the most important support teachers and caregivers can give a blooming reader is access to a variety of material and choice in selecting what they read. In school, certain reading is a requirement for assessment or curriculum, but in any free reading opportunity, students should have agency in what they read. By self-selecting a book, they are more likely to be invested in the reading experience and persist through it, even if it is a higher reading level (Edutopia).
Book selection is an important and personal process that should be tailored to the reader. Teachers and parents can help connect young readers to likely book prospects by engaging in conversations with them about their interests in school and beyond, and the genres they are drawn to (Literacy Worldwide). You can reference previous books they enjoyed, as well as movies, shows, and activities they love outside of school. Encourage their feelings of agency by supporting a surprising book choice and their potential decision to walk away from a book that does not spark their interest (Edutopia).
In addition to accessing reading material, having tools to determine fit is critical for young people to confidently self-select books. For younger readers, many teachers encourage the “five finger rule,” which means if there are five words on the second page they do not understand, the book may be too advanced (Reading Rockets). Some teachers encourage students to know their reading level directly and choose books based on that knowledge. One of the best resources for young readers to find and self-select just-right books are digital libraries like Rally Reader. With thousands of books from top publishers available, readers can search by reading level, grade, interest, and genre. Rally’s personalized book recommendations are popular with readers as well. When they finish a book they loved, a similar read is right there waiting for them. Helping children confidently choose great books supports their literacy development and fosters a lifelong joy of reading. Who knows - the next book they pick might just become their new favorite adventure!